ASL In the News

Defending Your Property Shouldn’t Cost You Everything

by | Nov 18, 2026 | ASL in the news, Farmers and Ranchers, Liberty Matters

Federal agencies should require proof of public need, exhaust alternatives and protect landowners before acquiring private property or enabling companies to condemn it

By Margaret Byfield

Across the country, homeowners are discovering that America’s next infrastructure boom could run straight through their backyards—and that protecting their property may require a legal fight they cannot afford.

A recent Wall Street Journal report documents those battles in Virginia, Georgia and Texas, as utilities expand transmission networks to accommodate data centers and other growth.

In Virginia, Vicky Hu is challenging a transmission project that would place a roughly 165-foot tower on her property. In Georgia, Cynthia Van Epps and her husband hired an attorney and ultimately reached an agreement to sell their home to a utility for demolition.

Their circumstances differ. The question confronting them is the same: What does the right to own property mean when defending it requires putting a family’s financial security at risk?

Utilities say these investments will strengthen reliability and meet growing electricity demand. Those are legitimate public objectives. But invoking them should begin the examination of a proposed condemnation, not end it.

Who needs the project? Who benefits? Were less disruptive alternatives exhausted? And why should the owner have to finance a prolonged legal battle to get those questions answered?

These disputes often begin under state law, but Washington has responsibilities of its own. Federal agencies acquire private property, review infrastructure proposals and make decisions that can enable companies to exercise federally granted condemnation authority. Wherever federal power makes a taking possible, protecting the property owner should be part of the government’s job.

On Nov. 9, the Supreme Court is scheduled to hear Hoffmann v. WBI Energy Transmission, involving North Dakota landowners whose property was condemned for a natural gas pipeline. The dispute concerns whether state compensation protections apply to private condemnations under the federal Natural Gas Act, including reimbursement of attorney and expert fees.

As the landowners’ brief explains, the federal appeals court rejected the application of those protections. If owners must spend a substantial portion of their compensation obtaining it, the public project’s costs fall especially hard on the people forced to surrender their property.

Federal responsibility also begins well before a compensation dispute reaches court. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission explains that its approval of a natural gas project can enable a company to exercise eminent domain under federal law when negotiations fail. The company brings the condemnation proceeding, and a court determines compensation.

The federal decision helps open the door. Federal officials should be accountable for what comes through it.

American Stewards of Liberty has developed six principles that should guide federal land acquisition and federal decisions enabling condemnation.

First, federal power must never be used to take property for private gain. When Washington acquires land itself or approves a project carrying federal condemnation authority, it should require a clear showing of public use. A company’s ability to earn more money from someone else’s land is no justification for compelling its transfer. Private beneficiaries warrant greater scrutiny because they stand to profit from exercising a power ordinary Americans do not possess.

Second, reserve federally authorized condemnation for essential public services. The Fifth Amendment requires public use and just compensation. Federal policy should demand an essential public use supported by evidence of need. Agencies should identify whom a project serves, why it is necessary and why taking private property is indispensable to providing that service. Promises of economic activity should never substitute for those answers.

Third, make condemnation a genuine last resort. Federal agencies should exhaust alternatives in their own acquisitions and, within their project-review authority, require applicants seeking condemnation powers to do the same. Existing rights of way, different routes, different designs and voluntary agreements deserve serious examination. Rejecting an owner’s alternative should require a documented explanation.

Fourth, give productive agricultural land priority in federal decisions. A farm or ranch contributes to the nation’s food supply and economic security. Federal acquisition and permitting reviews should treat that production as a national interest to protect, with priority over competing infrastructure and industrial uses. Officials should account for the operation as a whole, including whether a proposed easement would impair access, irrigation or continued agricultural use.

Fifth, put required federal permitting ahead of condemnation. Agencies should coordinate their reviews so owners do not face the loss or alteration of their property while essential federal approvals remain unresolved. Where current law allows condemnation before those approvals are secured, Congress should change that sequence. A developer should bear the risk that its proposal cannot obtain permission to proceed.

Sixth, make efficient land use a condition of federal support for energy projects requiring condemnation. In reviewing generation and transmission alternatives, agencies should require demonstrated necessity, an essential public purpose and selection of the most energy-dense viable alternative. The objective should be the greatest useful energy from the smallest necessary land footprint. Applicants should have to justify the amount of private land their plans would consume.

These principles belong in the decisions federal officials make before a property owner receives a condemnation notice.

Congress already has a federal acquisition policy favoring negotiation and rejecting coercive tactics to force agreement on price. That commitment should carry through federal acquisition practices and the statutory safeguards governing private use of federal condemnation authority.

Agencies should apply the protections their existing authority permits. Property owners deserve clear standards and a meaningful opportunity to challenge a proposed taking before irreversible harm occurs.

America needs dependable energy, functioning transportation and a secure food supply. Federal officials must pursue those goals with respect for the people whose land makes them possible.

Before Washington takes family property or enables someone else to take it, it should have to prove the need, exhaust the alternatives and account for what will be lost.

A family should never have to go broke to make Washington answer those questions.

Margaret Byfield is executive director of American Stewards of Liberty. This column first appeared in the Washington Signal.

Share this page...

STAY INFORMED

Subscribe to our weekly online analysis about the issues affecting your property rights.

Subscribe

Receive our quarterly journal that provides our insights into current and emerging property rights issues.
Free with membership.

Join Now

Get our action alerts so your voice will make an impact. (If you are a Member or Subscriber you are already signed up)

Sign Up

Issue Guides

Find the ASL issue guides here to help you with the background, talking points, and all the tools to educate your community. And it's free!

Learn More