Rule would translate statutory obligations into concrete regulatory requirements
The Bureau of Land Management has proposed revising decades-old federal land-use planning regulations as a way to reduce bureaucracy, speed decisions, and give state and local governments a more effective role in decisions affecting their communities.
Its proposed revision of planning regulations under the Federal Land Policy and Management Act (FLPMA) aims to streamline and modernize procedures, eliminate requirements the agency considers duplicative or unnecessary, and, most important, put federal coordination with state and local governments at the center of the proposed changes.
American Stewards of Liberty (ASL) has for years called attention to federal statutory requirements that agencies coordinate land-use decisions on federal lands with impacted state and local governments. This rule would take a big step toward implementing the law and satisfying congressional intent, though there are a few caveats.
According to the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), a newly created definition of coordination directs the agency to consider the plans and policies of non-federal governmental entities: “The BLM believes that the consideration of these plans is part of the coordination process that occurs during land use planning. … FLPMA’s coordination requirements ensure the BLM coordinates its planning with the planning and management programs of other federal agencies, state and local governments, and tribes.”
The proposed rule finally aligns BLM’s responsibilities for coordination during the land-use planning process with its legal obligations, officials say. Interior secretary Doug Burgum said the proposed definition of coordination is distinct to the BLM’s land use planning process and is based on Congress’s recognition that state, local, and tribal governmental entities play a unique and necessary role in land use planning.
“Public lands are set aside for the benefit and use of the American people,” Burgum said. “They should be managed by the people closest to the land, not held back by outdated bureaucracy in D.C. By empowering state and local leaders and cutting decades-old red tape, we’re making it easier to conserve our natural resources, boost production, and create a more affordable and abundant supply of food and energy for American families.”
The proposal has won the support of property-rights advocates who have long argued that coordination is a statutory requirement, not a suggestion.
“Through this proposed rule, the Trump administration is the first to direct the BLM to comply with the coordination provision Congress established through FLPMA in 1978. This gives local governments a meaningful path to see that the multiple-uses of these lands continue, the established use rights are respected, and local economies prosper,” commented Margaret Byfield, executive director of ASL.
The BLM published the proposed rule November 10. Public comments continue through January 11, 2027.
Why coordination matters
Coordination is a government-to-government process meant to reconcile federal management with state and local plans and policies. Specifically, it requires federal agencies to work with state and local governments to identify and address conflicts between federal land-use decisions and applicable state and local plans.
In recent years, it has become a powerful and often necessary tool used by state and local governments to fight ongoing land restrictions imposed by the federal government on federal lands, a massive modern encroachment never envisioned by the nation’s Founders, as U.S. Rep. Tom Tiffany (R-Wisconsin) has observed.
“The concept of coordination is firmly rooted in the constitutional principles of our nation,” Tiffany has said. “States and their local governments were never intended to be displaced by federal agencies determining and restricting the uses of their land within their jurisdiction.”
ASL’s Byfield says coordination requires federal agencies to adjust their plans to align with local plans, not the other way around.
“The statute requires the federal agency to make its plans consistent with the local plans as long as those plans align with the federal law and purpose for the law, in this case FLPMA,” Byfield explained. “This places the burden on the federal agency to provide a reasonable explanation for reducing livestock numbers, eliminating recreational access to specific lands, or barring other uses if the local plans and policies clearly state the need for these uses, and they are in alignment with the federal law.”
“This is also why it is important that local governments have robust plans in place that clearly express the needs of the communities, citizens, and local economies so that the federal agency has a clear understanding of these needs and can incorporate them into the federal plan.”
The government-to-government approach of coordination infuses federal decision-making with the institutional knowledge of local experts, and takes the handcuffs off state and local governments to help ensure that federal agency actions are meaningful, productive, and effective at ensuring robust local economies as well as good stewardship of the nation’s resources, ASL explains on its website.
The proposed rule goes a long way to doing just that. While some federal agencies have often resisted coordination—or ignored the requirements in reality—the proposed rule would help ensure that those obligations are met.
First, the rule would involve local governments from the outset of any land-use planning. Proposed § 1610.31(a)(1) expressly invites state and local governments and tribes to participate in developing, revising, or amending plans and to advise BLM on the general approach to planning, while proposed § 1610.41(a)(3) requires the agency to prepare a planning-area profile and analytical framework, including preliminary alternatives under consideration, and to make that document publicly available.
Under the proposed rule, BLM would be required to request and gather those plans before developing management alternatives, including information about land uses that those governments prohibit or restrict. That allows local concerns to shape the direction of planning rather than merely responding to decisions already made or taking shape.
“Under the proposed regulations, the BLM would coordinate earlier in the planning process with governors to identify concerns and gain information than it does under the present regulations,” the BLM states. “This advanced coordination would better inform the BLM’s development of management alternatives that address the issues and concerns raised by the [state’s] governor. This early engagement process is expected to result in the BLM identifying and addressing concerns early in the planning process, leading to more informed decision-making and reducing the need for a separate governor’s appeal process at the end of the planning process.”
However, the proposed rule would give state, local, and tribal governments only 45 calendar days after a BLM request to submit their existing approved resource-related plans and summaries of prohibited or restricted land uses for consideration during the early planning process. That requirement is intended to bring local concerns into the process sooner, though it could make it difficult for some smaller counties to respond in a timely fashion.
The rule would also shorten the governor’s consistency review from 60 to 30 days and eliminate the governor’s ability to appeal to the BLM director, again because the BLM asserts that earlier participation makes such appeals redundant.
Still, Public Lands Council representative Kathryn Glover says the new rule would allow local governments to participate in the early stages of planning rather than waiting until later: “It’s designed to make that process more efficient and to be able to use information as part of the front end of that process,” she told Tri-State Livestock News.
Coordination formally defined
In addition to earlier participation, the new rule sets out a formal definition of coordination. Though existing federal regulations require the BLM to coordinate with state and local governments, the proposed rule would formally define the term for the first time in the planning regulations, emphasizing government participation and advice.
“Coordination during the land use planning process means inviting the participation of Federal agencies, state and local governments, and Indian tribes germane to the planning area in the development, revision, or amendment of a land use plan to advise on the general approach of the planning effort as representatives of people and institutions that are affected by decisions made in land use plans,” the BLM states.
That expressly recognizes governments as more than ordinary members of the commenting public and distinguishes FLPMA coordination from National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) cooperating-agency participation. And while it does not necessarily mean reaching agreement with state or local governments, it gives those governments a guaranteed seat at the table at an earlier stage—something they have not always actually had in practice before.
The rule actually invokes the 1970 Public Land Law Review Commission’s recognition that “these governments represent the people and institutions that will be most directly affected by Federal programs growing out of land use planning.”
The proposal also clarifies that approved resource-related plans include policies.
“The BLM would also clarify that the definition of ‘approved resource-related plans’ in paragraph (b)(1) of this section includes approved resource-related ‘policies,’” the BLM states. “These proposed regulations also use the term ‘approved resource-related plans’ or ‘plans’ when referring to plans or policies adopted by state, local, and tribal governments in discussions at ‘Preparing for planning,’ ‘Governor’s consistency review,’ and ‘Local governments’ consistency review.’”
The proposal replaces the phrase “officially approved and adopted” with “approved” and specifies that plans must be authorized under the relevant government’s constitution, legislation, or charter.
Giving consistency greater force
While coordination may inform consistency, FLPMA has a separate requirement that BLM land use plans be consistent with state and local plans to the maximum extent the secretary finds consistent with federal law and the purposes of FLPMA. The formulation is a proposed regulatory clarification of an existing statutory obligation from Congress.
“Consistent means that, as a general rule, no use of public land should be permitted which is prohibited by approved resource-related plans of state or local governments that are germane to the development of land use plans for public lands, unless such use is found by the Bureau of Land Management to be in the national interest,” the BLM states.
This language is important because it establishes a presumption against allowing federal land uses prohibited by applicable state or local resource-related plans, hardwiring into rule a principle articulated by the 1970 Public Land Law Review Commission.
That would make the consistency standard more concrete for counties. A separate proposed local-government consistency review would also allow local officials to present proposed resolutions directly to BLM rather than routing local inconsistencies through the governor.
“The BLM is proposing local governments’ consistency review procedures that would establish a new opportunity for local government officials to submit recommendations to resolve inconsistencies directly to the BLM prior to the BLM’s approval of the plan, revision, or amendment,” BLM states. “This process is separate from the governor’s consistency review process but would run concurrently with that process. Under the current regulations, the BLM submits inconsistencies with local plans to a state’s governor for resolution. The proposed change would provide local government officials the opportunity to directly present recommendations to the BLM to resolve inconsistencies without going through the governor’s office.”
It’s important to note, though, that while the proposed rule would give local governments a new opportunity to challenge inconsistencies directly, the trade off is that it would allow them only 30 calendar days to do so. If timely challenges are not made, the inconsistencies would be presumed resolved.
The BLM rule also strikes other federal agencies and tribes from consistency requirements because, the agency states, the FLPMA does not direct the BLM to be consistent with those plans and only provides for consistency with state and local government plans.
The strongest caution is that greater access at the front end is paired with a narrower window for objections at the back end. Whether that tradeoff works will depend on how effectively concerns are addressed at the beginning.
Other provisions
Other changes in the broader planning overhaul include how boundaries of planning areas will be drawn.
“The proposed rule removes language specifying a boundary delineation, allowing maximum flexibility to identify planning areas that make sense to on-the-ground management, rather than a default of BLM district or field office administrative boundaries,” the BLM states.
The BLM is also proposing significant changes to public involvement in planning.
“The proposed rule sets a baseline requirement that is less rigid than the current regulations,” the BLM stated. “The proposed rule would allow the BLM greater flexibility to determine the appropriate public participation for the areas and people involved in the specific planning process. For example, the current regulations require planning efforts, including amendments, that are supported by environmental impact statements to hold a minimum of a 90-day public comment period on the draft plan. A 90-day minimum public comment period is more than double the comment period formerly required under the Council on Environmental Quality’s regulations for implementing the procedural requirements of the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), which the Council on Environmental Quality rescinded.”
There is also no corresponding public comment requirement in either NEPA or the Department of the Interior’s 2026 NEPA procedures, the BLM states.
“With the requirement to complete environmental impact statements in two years absent an extension, a 90-day public comment period is burdensome to BLM’s ability to comply with NEPA,” the agency states. “Furthermore, use of a long comment period as reliance for quality public engagement is not always the right approach for each planning effort. The proposed procedures introduce flexibility to the process, so that the BLM can formulate public involvement in a manner that appropriately supports the planning effort.”
BLM says that would allow the agency to determine whether the minimum required public engagement would be adequate while ensuring that BLM could meet the statutory requirements under NEPA for timely completion of analysis.
“The BLM could hold a public meeting in lieu of a comment period when permissible under other authorities—such as NEPA—and when adequate notice to the public is provided,” BLM states. “As an example, the BLM may need to conduct amendments to consider changes to land tenure decisions to allow small parcels of public lands to be made available for disposal, to address unintentional trespass, or to provide sales to communities. A plan amendment of this nature is generally only of interest to the local community, and a public meeting may be able to be held to provide for more engaged involvement and allow the analysis to progress more quickly, without the delay of needing to wait for a 30-day comment period.”
In addition, the agency stated that the proposed regulations do not restrict the BLM from holding both a comment period and public meetings for a planning effort when doing so would best support the analysis.
The proposed rule would also eliminate the requirement for an environmental impact statement as the NEPA level required to support the development or revision of a land use plan.
“The level of NEPA required would no longer be governed by planning regulations,” the BLM states. “It would be subject to review under the current NEPA procedures to determine the level of analysis that would be appropriate.”
Finally, the rule would make changes to Areas of Critical Environmental Concern (ACEC) that BLM says would allow it to focus special management on lands in need of protection rather than on oversized buffer areas, according to the agency.
The statutory designation criteria would remain in place, but nominations made outside a planning process would generally be deferred until a subsequent relevant planning effort. Then, too, the proposal removes an ACEC-specific 60-day draft-plan comment requirement, though BLM says public input on ACECs would remain possible during other comment opportunities.
The central question
For coordination proponents, the proposal represents more than a welcome acknowledgment that counties and states have a distinctive role in decisions affecting federal lands and surrounding communities. It does that, but, more than mere acknowledgment, it would translate existing statutory obligations into explicit regulatory requirements and procedures. Rather than merely presuming coordination will occur, the rule would require earlier engagement, establish clear standards for that engagement, and provide local governments a direct path to challenge inconsistencies between federal and local land-use plans.
Those gains are not unconditional. FLPMA already requires coordination and federal officials retain final decision-making authority. Unquestionably, though, while coordination never guarantees a resolution of land-use inconsistencies in favor of state and local governments, the new rule guarantees those governments a seat at the table from the beginning of the process, and endows them with the meaningful influence that comes with it.





